John Brooks referees Newcastle v Everton on Monday night. Everton have never won a Premier League game with him as the man in the middle, and on our data he is the least favourable official in their history.
Newcastle v Everton, St James’ Park, Monday 2 November, 8pm UK time. Referee: John Brooks. VAR: Paul Howard.
The number every Everton fan will be talking about
Fourteen games. No wins.
That is Everton’s Premier League record when John Brooks has been the on-field referee, going back to the start of our data in the 2021/22 season. Of those 14 games, six have been draws and eight have been defeats.
On Monday night he takes charge of Newcastle v Everton, so the run will either go on or finally end at St James’ Park.
The full Premier League record
Across those 14 games with Brooks as referee, Everton have:
- won 0
- drawn 6
- lost 8
- scored 11 goals
- conceded 27 goals
The draws include goalless games away at Fulham and Crystal Palace and a 2-2 at Nottingham Forest. The defeats include a 4-0 loss at Old Trafford in December 2024 and a 3-1 home loss to Sunderland in May 2026.
Last time out
The most recent of those 14 games was only two months ago. Everton hosted Manchester United at the Hill Dickinson Stadium on 6 September and twice fell behind, to goals from Bryan Mbeumo and Benjamin Sesko. Tyrique George levelled the first time, and Ainsley Maitland-Niles curled in a stoppage-time equaliser on his debut to make it 2-2.
It was a point rescued at the death, and it kept the record at no wins.
Where Brooks ranks for Everton
On whosthatref.com, every official gets a Ref Performance Score, or RPS, for each club. In plain words, it is our 0 to 5 score for how decisions have gone for a club under a ref. It looks at win rate, goal difference and cards, compared with league averages, and it is adjusted for major decisions we have tracked since 2024/25. A score of 2.5 is neutral.
Here is how to read it:
- 0 to 1: very unfavourable
- 1 to 2: unfavourable
- 2 to 3: neutral
- 3 to 4: favourable
- 4 to 5: very favourable
For Everton, John Brooks scores 0.33. That puts him in the very unfavourable band and makes him the lowest-rated of all 36 officials we track for Everton. Chris Kavanagh is next on 0.40.
This score uses a wider sample than the 14-game record above. It covers 26 Premier League games where Brooks was involved with Everton, either as referee (14 games) or as VAR (12 games). Everton have won 4 of those 26 games (15%), scoring 20 and conceding 44. All four wins came in games where Brooks was on VAR duty rather than refereeing.
RPS measures patterns in results, not intent. A low score does not mean a referee is against a club. It simply shows how things have gone for that club when he has been involved.

The Newcastle contrast
The picture is very different for the home side. Newcastle have played 22 games with Brooks involved and have won half of them (50%). Their RPS with him is 2.66, which sits in the neutral band. Their results under him are broadly in line with their results under everyone else.
So one side comes into Monday with a neutral record under this referee. The other has a 14-game wait for a Premier League win under him.
Who is on VAR?
The VAR is Paul Howard, with Stuart Burt as assistant VAR. It is the same referee and VAR pairing as that 2-2 with Manchester United in September.
Here is what Howard’s record shows so far.
With Everton (7 Premier League games): Everton have won 3, drawn 2 and lost 2, scoring 11 and conceding 8. His RPS for Everton is 2.11, which is neutral. The most memorable VAR check of his with Everton came at Old Trafford in November 2025. Idrissa Gueye was shown a straight red card by referee Tony Harrington for slapping his own team-mate Michael Keane, and Howard checked and confirmed it as a “clear strike to the face”. Everton still won 1-0 with ten men.
With Newcastle (4 Premier League games): Newcastle have won 2 and lost 2. His RPS for them is 2.77, also neutral, though four games is a small sample and should be treated with caution. His busiest night with them came against Burnley at St James’ Park in December 2025. He sent referee Stuart Attwell to the pitchside monitor twice, and both checks ended in handball penalties, one for each side. Newcastle won 2-1.
What his record shows: with both clubs, Howard’s numbers sit in the neutral band. On our data, Monday’s story is far more about the referee than about the VAR.
Explore the numbers
You can see Everton’s full game-by-game history under John Brooks, along with every other official, at whosthatref.com/team/everton/referee/john-brooks. You can also look up Brooks at whosthatref.com/referee/john-brooks and Paul Howard at whosthatref.com/referee/paul-howard.
Data covers the Premier League from 2021/22 onwards. Major decisions are tracked from 2024/25. Figures correct as of 2 November 2026.





